Assessment of Good governance in Decentralized city Administration: Case of Mekelle Municipality


Assessment of Good governance in Decentralized city Administration: Case of Mekelle Municipality


Fitsum Abrha
Mekelle University, College of Business and Economics, Department of Management


Journal of Modern Economy

This study was conducted to assess good governance practice by taking the variables responsiveness and transparency among the other good governance manifestations. For this rationale, the land administration and urban planning and development offices were purposively selected. Provision of effective, efficient and quality service to the constituents is manifestation of improving good governance practice. So, there is a need to ensure good governance practice in the realm of service provision in the offices of land administration and urban planning and development. The general objective of the study is to assess the practice of good governance in Mekelle city administration. Accordingly, transparency and responsiveness which are the main indicators of good governance had used to assess the governance situation in the public institutions’ of land administration and urban planning and development offices. The study used 153 purposely selected sample respondents from the selected sub cities that are Ayder and Hawelti sub cities and both qualitative and quantitative data analysis techniques were used accordingly. In order to gather the necessary data from the sample respondents, Questionnaire and interview were used data collection tools. In this regard descriptive statistics was employed to analyze the data obtained via questionnaire. The findings of the study show that there is lack of accessibility of information, limited Capacity (competence) of the offices and human power, discrimination, corruption and rent seeking behavior from the bureaucrats, delay of decisions, material and human resource, low level of skill and knowledge, lack of openness and low satisfaction from the constituents’, dishonesty, low level of motivation and commitment irresponsiveness are considered the main hindrances’ of good governance in the city administration in general and the selected public institutions in particular. So, transparency and responsiveness had compromised in the land administration and urban planning and development offices which are the most indicators of good governance. Therefore, there should be more and deeper inquiry.

Free Full-text PDF


How to cite this article:
Fitsum Abrha. Assessment of Good governance in Decentralized city Administration: Case of Mekelle Municipality. Journal of Modern Economy, 2018,1:2. DOI:10.28933/jme-2018-01-0801


References:
1. Abdellatif Good. (nd).Korea Governance and Its Relationship to Democracy &Economic
2. Development, Governance Programme Advisor Regional Bureau for Arab State,UNDP
3. Abdulahi (2008).Ethiopia: Decentralization of Primary Education Service delivery to the district: A Comparative Study between Somali Region and South NationHague, Netherlands
4. ADB AND ADF.(2009).Federal democratic republic of Ethiopia country governance profileregion governance, economic & financial reforms department (osge) country department east (oreb)
5. AGGN Research and Publication Committee (2010) Germany:Addressing Good Governance In Africa, ADiscussion AGGN Research and Publication 1st AGGN Seminar held on21st – 27th of March, in Bonn, Germany
6. Akokpar.(2004).The AU,NEPAD and the Promotion of Good Governance in AfricaNordic Journal of African Studies ,University of Cape Town, South Africa
7. Arko-Adjei,J. de Jong, J. Zevenbergen, A. Tuladhar (2010),Customary tenure institutions
8. Andrew Sunil Rajkumar (2008).Ethiopia: Achieving better service delivery in Ethiopia: Africa human development series, World bank
9. Andrews and Shah.(2003).Assessing Local Government Performance in developing countries Washington Dc: The World Bank.
10. Anello, Eloy, (2006), Ethical Infrastructure for Good Governance in the Public Pharmaceutical Sector, working draft for field testing and revision, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland
11. Anwar shah.(nd).local governance in developing countries Public Sector Governance And Accountability Series local Governance,World Bank
12. Arsano (2010).Governance and Drivers of Change in Ethiopia’s Water SupplySector, study conducted by the Organisation for Social Science Research in Eastern and Southern Africa (OSSREA) in collaboration with the Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
13. Azfar, Kähkönen, Lanyi, and Rutherford.(1999). Decentralization, Governance And Public Services,The Impact Of Institutional Arrangements,IRIS Center, University of Maryland, College Park
14. Barnett, C. and Minis, H. et al. (1997). Democratic Decentralization: The paper prepared for the USAID under the IQC for Democracy and Governance, Contract No. AEP-5468- I-00-6014-00, Task 1, Delivery Order 2: Use of Incentives to Encourage Devolution of Central Authority/Resources to Local Governments. Research Triangle Institute.
15. Belay.(2012).Assessment of Governance and Administration of Urban Land: of Abi Adi Town, Tigray Regional State, Ethiopia
16. Berhanu (2003) Ethiopia. municipal development partnership for eastern and southern Africa city/municipal management strategy ,Addis Ababa
17. Berhanu .(2009).Ethiopia, Note on Fiscal Federalism, Service Delivery and Capacity Building: ,Abuja, Nigeria, Economic Commission for Africa,in collaboration with The World Bank
18. Berhanu Legesse (2008), Note on Fiscal Federalism, Service Delivery and Capacity Building: The Case of Ethiopia
19. Bhatta (1998). Governance Innovations in the Asian-Pacific Region: Trends Causes and Issues. USA
20. Bevir (nd).Governance as Theory,Practice, and Dilemma
21. Blair, H. (2000). Participation and Accountability at the Periphery: Democratic Local Governance in Six Countries. World Development 28 (1): 21-39.
22. Bloom (2004).Governance Matters The role of governance in Asian economic development
23. Braathen, Chaligha and Fjeldstad.(2005).Local governance, finances and service delivery in Tanzania
24. Brempong (2011).Is bilateral aid responding to good governance in Africa,camorron
25. Cabral .(2011).Decentralization in Africa:Scope,Motivations and Impact on Service Deliver and Poverty, Overseas Development Institute, Working Paper 020 www.future- agricultures.org
26. Cammack (2007).Neopatrimonial Politics,Decentralisation and Local Government: Uganda and Malawi
27. Carrington (2008).The Theory of Governance & Accountability, the University ofIowa Center for International Finance and Development Catherine Boone (nd).Decentralization as apolitical strategy in West Africa Cheema and Rondinelli .(nd). From Government Decentralization to Decentralized Governance
28. Cheema and Rondinelli.(2007), Decentralizing Governance, Emerging Concepts and Practice , Ash institute for democratic governance and innovation, John F.Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Washington, D.C.
29. Chigbu (2011). Germany.on grooming good governance in Africa:a scrutiny on good governance
30. Crook .(2005).Decentralization and Good Governance, Forum of Federations United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD) in the African family,faculty of civil geo and environmental engineering, technische universität münchen,
31. Chowdhur and Skarsted, (2005).The Principle of Good Governance, ALegal Working Paper in the CISDL “Recent Developments in International Law Related to Sustainable Development” Series1Open Draft FOR Review, Oxford, Kingdom
32. Cheema and Rondinelli(2005). From Government Decentralization to Decentralized Governance
33. Chaudhry .(2009).Factors Affecting Good Governance in Pakistan: AnEmpirical Analysis Damayanti. (2004).sustaining participation in local Governance,Sustaining participation at local governance case of pdpp (participatory medium term development planning) inIndonesia
34. Dessalegn . (2008 )Ethiopia. CSOs/NGOs in Ethiopia Partners in Development and Good govern ance,A Report Prepared for the Ad Hoc CSO/NGO Task Force,Addis Ababa
35. Devas.(2005).Global Forum on Fighting Corruption: The Challenges of Decentralization International Development Department School of Public Policy University of Birmingham ,England
36. DFID, Research Strategy (2008 – 2013), Consultation – Africa, Country Report for Ethiopia, 5th December, CABI Africa.
37. Dick .(2008).Decentralization, pro-poor land policies, and democraticgovernance,International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI),London School of Economics and Political Science,UNDP
38. Dickovick and Tegegne.(2010).Comparative Assessment of Decentralization in Africa: Ethiopia Desk Study,USAID
39. Duvanova. (2008).DO Civil Service Reforms Lead TO Better Governance? Kazakhstan’S Experience ,Department of Political Science University at Buffalo,annual meetin goftheAmericanPoliticalScienceAssociation,http://www.polsci.buffalo.edu/faculty
40. Egbenya.(2009).The effectiveness of decentralization policy in Ghana , African Journal of Political Science and International Relations, Department of Sociology, University of Cape Coast, Ghana.
41. Earle and Zoë scott. (2010).Assessing The evidence of the impact of Governance odevelopment outcomes and poverty reduction,uk department for international development (dfid) through the emerging issues research service of the governance and socio development resource centre (gsdrc).
42. Ekpo. (2008).Nigeria :Decentralization and Service delivery: A department of economics university of Oyo
43. Faguet .(1997).Decentralization and local Government Performance Centre for Economic Perfor mance and Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics
44. FDRE Constitution(1995)
45. Gebreslassie.(2011).Challenges of Good Governance in Local Government: The case of SaesieTsaedamba Woreda, Tigray Region, Ethiopia
46. Gisselquist (2012).Good Governance as a Concept, and Why This Matters for Development Policy, world institute for development economics Research,United Nations Gray and khan (nd) Tanzania :Good governance and growth in Africa: what can we learn from
47. Greville.(2004).Research Report commissioned by the Chief Directorate District Development and Monitoring ,Province of the Eastern Cape,Department of Education
48. Grindle (2010).Good Governance The Inflation of an Idea Faculty Research Working Paper Series ,Harvard Kennedy School
49. Gulyani et al.(2001).Municipal Decentralization in Ethiopia:A Rapid Assessment
50. Helling, Serrano and Warren.(2005).Linking Community Empowerment, Decentralized Governance and Public Service Provision through a Local Development Framework,SP Discussion Paper,NO.0535 Helvetas Ethiopia (2008),Woreda Good Governance Support Project in
51. Heywood, A. (2003) Politics: An Introduction. Palgrave foundation
52. Huther and shah.(2003).Measuring Government Performance in the Delivery of Public services.washington D.c: the World Bank
53. Islam (2003).Decentralized governance and development in India: a study in west Bengal development administration unit institute for social and economic change ,university of mysore
54. IFAD (1999) Rome: International Fund For Agricultural development Executive Board – Sixty- Seventh Session, Institutional governance review.(nd).Issues in state transformation: Decentralization, Delivery and democracy institution Development, Performance Management and citizen charters, centre for good governance
55. John, N. (2002). Local governance for rural poverty reduction
56. Joshi (2010).Impact and Effectiveness of Transparency and Accountability and Service Delivery Kassahun, B. & Tegegne, G. (2004). Citizen participation in the decentralization process in Ethiopia; A consultancy report submitted to the Ministry of Capacity Building, GoE, Addis Ababa.
57. Katsiaouni (2002).Decentralization and Poverty Reduction : Does it Work? :Linking dece tralized Governance and Human Development (UNDP, UNCDF, WBI and UN- DESA)Fifth GlobalForumonReinventingGovernment(Interactive WorkshopDecentralised Governance)
58. Katsriku.(2012).A presentation On The Topic “Promoting Good Governance And Accountability In The public service , Chairman of the public service Commission
59. Kaufmann, D., Kraay, D., & Mastruzzi, M. (2007).Governance matters VI: governance Kauzya. (2003).Local Governance Capacity-Building for Full-Range Participation, Concepts, Frameworks and Experiences in African Countries, United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs
60. Kiwanuka (nd) Uganda. Decentralization and Good governance in Africa,institutional challenges to Uganda’s local governments Management Consultant, Uganda Management Institute, Kampala
61. Kpundeh and Khadiagala. (2008),Information Access, Governance, and ServiceDelivery in Key
62. Sectors: Themes and Lessons from Kenya and Ethiopia, public sector governance,Worled Bank
63. Ladi (2008).Good governance and public Administration Reform in the Black Sea economic cooperation (bsec) Member states, International Centre for Black Sea Studies
64. Manasanl etal.(1999).Indicators of Good Governance: Developing an Index of Governance Quality at the LGU Level, Discussion Paper Series NO. 99-04, Philippine Institute for Development Studies
65. Marito Garcia and Andrew.(n.d.).Achieving better service delivery Mbao and komboni (nd) Botswana .Promotion of good governance and combating corruption and maladministration
66. Meheret Ayenew .(2007). Rapid Assessment of Woreda Decentralization
67. Mekolo and Resta .(2005).Governance Progress in Africa: Challe and Trends,Division for Public Administration and Development Management, United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs
68. Meheret (2001).Municipal Decentralization in Ethiopia
69. Mezgebe (2007). Beginning To Begin, Good Governance in the Next Ethiopian Millennium
70. Miller(2002).Advantages &Disadvantages of Local Government Decentralization, Caribbean conference on local government & Decentralization at the ocean view International hotel Georgetown, Guyana
71. Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED) (2010). The Federal Democratic
72. Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED) (2010) The Federal Democratic
73. Republic of Ethiopia Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP) 2010/11-2014/15 Draft ,Addis Ababa.
74. Ministry of Finance and Economic Development. (2009).Financial Transparency and Accountability Perception Survey, Macro Economy Policy and Management ,Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Mohanty(nd).Transparency and Accountability in Municipal Governance
75. Ministry of works and urban development (2005/06-2009/10).Plan for urban development and urban good governance, plan for accelerated and sustained development to end poverty , plan for urban development and urban good governance, federal democratic republic of Ethiopia.
76. Misuraca. (2007).e-Governance in Africa International Development Research Centre ,Ottawa
77. Momen and Begum. (2005).challenges of good governance in Bangladish,University of Rajshahi
78. Mugabi .(nd).Decentralization for Good Governance: Policies, Legal Frameworks and Implementation Strategies
79. Muhammad .(2006) Ethiopia. The performance of woreda decentralization program in Amhara national regional state
80. Mulugeta. ( 2012 ).Decentralization in Ethiopia: concept and process the case of Dendi district, west Shoa Zone of Oromia state Dortmund ,Germany
81. Negalegn. (2010). Ethiopia. An assessment of the current status of decentralized governance and self-administration in Amhara national regional state: Department of administration and development management ,Addis Ababa
82. NEPAD (2007).African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM)
83. NEPAD (2007). Governance in Africa’s development: Progress, Prospects and Challenges
84. Nyong’(2001).Kenya. Governance and Poverty Reduction in Africa the African Academy of Sciences, the African Development Bank, Kenya
85. Odi briefing paper (2006).Governance, Development and aid Effectiveness: quick guide to complex Relationships
86. Osmani, S.R. (2000). Participatory Governance, People’s Empowerment and Poverty Reduction SEPED Conference Series 7. New York: UNDP/SEPED. [http://www.undp.org/seped/publications/
87. Oviasuyi, W. Idada and Isiraojie.(2010).Constraints of Local Government Administration in Nigeria
88. Parigi, Geeta and Rameesh. (2004).Ushering in Transparency for Good Governance Centre for Good Governance, Hyderabad
89. Peace building Commission.(2007). Local Governance and Decentralization in Post War Contexts, Working Group on Lessons Learned Background Note
90. Pretorius and Schurink (2007).Enhancing service delivery in Local Government: The Case of a district Municipality dalené pretorius department of human resource Management , university of Johannesburg
91. Popic & Mahesh (2011) Patel. Decentralization: Equity and Sect oral Policy implications for UNICEF in East-Asia and the Pacific social policy and economic analysis unit UNICEF eapro, Bangkok
92. Punyaratabandhu.(2004).Thailand: commitment to good governance development, and poverty reduction: A Paper Prepared for the Sixth Session of the Committee on Development Policy: National Institute of Development Administration, Bangkok.
93. Report of the Commission on Global Governance (1995).Good governance the concept
94. Rhodes (1997).Understanding Governance, Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity
95. Ribot (2001) USA.local actors, powers and accountability in African decentralizations: review of issues paper prepared for international development research centre Canada Assessment of social policy reforms initiative, Washington
96. Robert S. Chase and Anushay Anjum .(2008). Demand for Good Governance Initiatives Supporting Demand for Good Governance (DFGG), Across World Bank Group Sectors and Regions Community Driven Development & Local Governance Team ,Social Development Department, The World Bank
97. Robertson.(2002).InternationalConferenceonDecentralisationFederalism:TheFutureDecentralizig States? Overview of Decentralization Worldwide Manila,PhilippinesAStepping Stone to Improved Governance and Human Development, UNDP Robertson .(nd). The Role of Participation and Partnership in Decentralized Governance, A Brief Synthesis of Policy Lessons and Recommendations of Nine Country Case Studies on Service Delivery for the Poor, UNDP, New York
98. Rondinelli (1981) .Government Decentralization in Comparative Perspective: Theory and Practice in Developing Countries, International Review of Administrative Science
99. Sansom.(2009) Australia. Common wealth journal of local governance Centre for Local Government, University of Technology Sydney
100. Sebudubudu .(2010).The impact of good governance on development and poverty in Africa: Botswana ,A relatively successfulAfrican initiative,University of Botswana, Gaborone Shah(nd).AComparative Institutional Framework for Responsive, Responsible,andAccountable Local Governance For forms of government let fools contest;What best administer’dis best.
101. Shinkaiye.(2006).Governance Challenges in Africa And The Role OF The African Union Public Lecture to mark the 20th Anniversary of the European Centre for Development Policy Management, (ECDPM) 19 December (European Institute for Public Administration)Onze Lieve Vrouweplein 21, Maastricht, Netherlands
102. Singh, N. (2007(. (edn.). Decentralization and Legal Empowerment of the Poor. In Cheema, G. And Rondinelli, A. 2007. Decentralizing Governance: Emerging Concepts and Practices. John F.Kennedy School of Government Harvard University Brookings institution press Washington, D.C
103. Siri Gloppen, LiseRakner,ArneTostensen .(2003).Responsiveness to the concerns of the poor and accountability to the commitment to poverty reduction Smith, B. C.(2007), Good Governance and Development; Palgrave Macmillan
104. Stoker .(2006).Local Governance Research:Paradigms,Theories and Implications, Zhejiang University
105. Tangier.(2002).Good Governance Public Administration Challenges & Opportunities, Zambia
106. Tegegne, G. (1998). The influences of decentralization on some aspects of local and regional development planning in Ethiopia. Eastern Africa Social Science Research Review Tegegne and Tsegaye .(nd).Decentralization in Ethiopia., Forum of social studies, Addis Ababa
107. Tempo.(2010).Strengthening citizen demand for good governance in the African Context UK Department for International Development (DFID) or the Mwananchi partner Organizations.
108. Tim .(2003).Decentralization and Development Planning: Some Practical Considerations
109. Uddin (2010). Denmark:Impact of Good Governance on Development in Bangladesh,Institute of Society and Globalization Roskilde University R
110. Uddin. (2008) .Denmark. Does the Good Governance impact on the local development in Bangladesh?, Roskilde University
111. UN .(2007) .Good Governance practices for the protection of human rights office of the united nations high commissioner for human rights,New-york and Geneva
112. UN.(2005).Towards Participatory and Transparent Governance: Reinventing Government Publication based on6th Global Forum on Reinventing Government: towards Participatory and Transparent Governance, Department of Economic and Social Affairs Division for Public Administration and Development Management, Seoul, Republic of Korea
113. UN-HABITAT (2007). Transparency in land administration: a capacity building UNDESA(2006):Decentralization and Decentralized Governance for enhancing delivery of services in transition conditions
114. UNESC.(2006):Definition of basic concepts and terminologies in governance and Public administration, Compendium of basic terminology in governance and public administration
115. UNDP. (2001).Introducing Good Local Governance, The Indonesian Experience
116. UNDP.(nd).The Role of Participation and Partnership in Decentralized Governance, New York
117. UNDP .(2005). Governance for the future: Democracy and Development in the least Developed
118. countries
119. UNDP and ECA.(2002).Mozambique: Local Governance for Poverty Reduction in Africa Maputo
120. UNECFE (2008).Guide book on promoting good governance in public private partnerships, New York and Geneva UNESCFAP. (ND).what is good governance, The Asian pacific
121. United Nations Economic and Social Council (2006) USA: Definition of basic concepts and terminologies in governance and public, Committee of Experts on Public Administration administration, New York
122. United Nations.(2002).Decentralized Governance for Democracy, Peace, Development and Effective Service Delivery, Department of Economic and Social Affairs United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD)(2001).LOCAL actors, Powers and accountability in African Decentralizations: International Development
123. UNESC.(2006),Definition of basic concepts and terminologies in governance and public administration
124. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs.(2001).Decentralized Governanc for Democracy, Peace, Development and Effective Service Delivery
125. United Nation, (2007) .Good Governance Practices For the Protection of human rights, Office of the United nations High Commissioner for human rights ,New york and Geneva UN-HABITAT .(2002). Local democracy and decentralization in east and southern Africa USAID (nd).Democracy, human rights and governance.
126. United Nations Human Settlements Programme (2004), tools to support transparency in local governance
127. Van der Loop, Theo, ed,(2002),Local Democracy and Decentralization in Ethiopia, Regional and Local Development Studies (RLDS), Addis Ababa University,United Nations Huma Settlements Programs
128. Waheduzzaman.(nd).Good Governance in democratic developing Countries: A Paradox, School of Management, Victoria University, Melbourne, Australia
129. Wellington and Innocent.(2009).Urban Local Governance in the crucible: empirical overtones of central government meddling in local urban councils affairs in Zimbabwe Wilde et al.(nd). A Users’ Guide to Measuring Local Governance, UNDP Oslo Governance Centre
130. Wood, A. (2005). Demystifying ‘Good Governance’: an overview of World Bank Governance Reforms and Conditions.
131. World Bank.(2008),World Wide Governance Indicators (WGI)
132. World Bank .(2009 ),Local Government Discretion and Accountability: Application of a Local Governance Framework, Social Development Department
133. Yigremew, A. (2001). Decentralization and local governance in post-Derg Ethiopia. In Proceedings of the Conference on Governance and Sustainable Development: Promoting Collaborative Partnership, Addis Ababa.
134. Yilmaz and Venugopal (2008).Local Government Discretion andAccountability in Ethiopia, The World Bank“Obstacles to Decentralization,Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, International Studies Program, Georgia State University
135. Zemelak.(2008).Local government in Ethiopia: Adequately Empowered,University of the Western Cape
136. Zemelak (2009).Decentralization and Local Governance in Ethiopia Local Government Bulletin Conference
137. Zemelak .(2011), Local government in Ethiopia: still an apparatus of control? Doctoral intern with Local Democracy, State, Peace and Human Security Programme, Community Law Centre, University of the Western Cape Zoë Scott (nd).Topic Guide on service Delivery, Governance and Social Development resource centre ,Birmingham